I
am going to start this blog different than all of my other blogs and rate it on
the grading scale first and then give my reasoning’s behind the grade. I am
giving this book, like many other books, an A (I love mostly all books). I am
giving it an A because even though it was talking about the culture differences
between white kids and Indian kids I felt that it was very polite about it and
respectful. I was not once offended while reading this book. In fact I enjoyed
how he gave both sides of the story showing that the kids from Reardan had
problems of their own. They may not have been life threatening like drunken
parents or going hungry but they did have their own problems to deal with. Like
fathers who ignored them, and girls who puke to feel in control of their life;
and by setting the story in a somewhat humorous manner I did not feel
uncomfortable reading the story and was able to have a greater appreciation for
the severity of what was going on because I was not guilt tripped into it or
made to believe that it was my fault. But rather I was made more culturally
aware that it was happening and that people were suffering from it. Through-out
the novel Arnold or Junior which ever you prefer developed into becoming my
friend, I wanted to be his friend, and so listening to his complaints about
life did not bother me. I do not feel like it leaves anyone out gender or
culture wise because the author does such a nice job of not having a bias that
you can just appreciate the story. This text appeals to young adults because it
shows the struggle of identity and discovering who you are and what your
purpose is in life. But it puts it in a perspective that is enlightening. It
shows how the process of discovering yourself is a positive and can be joyous
and it is not as depressed or horrible as everyone wants you to believe it is.
Because even after the many struggles Arnold went through like losing three
members of his family he was still able to find happiness in life and strive
for his goals. That is why I gave this book a perfect score.
Broooke--I really appreciate what you say here and I think this is a testament to Alexie's writing. It's difficult to write something where you talk about white privilege and not offend people. He does it in such a way that makes us think and reflect, but is so honest and relatable. Thank you for highlighting that!
ReplyDelete